How to Identify Mccoy Pottery

Attention all antique collectors and pottery enthusiasts! Are you fascinated by the intricate details and timeless designs of vintage items? If so, then you may have come across Mccoy Pottery – a popular brand that has captivated many with its unique pieces. However, with the rising demand for these collectibles, it becomes increasingly difficult to authenticate them from knock-offs.

But fear not, as this blog post will guide you on how to identify Mccoy Pottery and add valuable pieces to your collection. With its rich history dating back over 160 years and countless variations of style and patterns, recognizing true Mccoy Pottery can be daunting but equally rewarding.

So join me as we dive into the world of this iconic brand in search of authentic treasures for our collections. Get ready to become a pro at identifying McCoy Pottery!

9 Best Ways on How How to Identify Mccoy Pottery

1. Look for the Mccoy Mark:

The most obvious way to identify Mccoy Pottery is by its distinct trademark. From 1925, all McCoy pottery was marked with “McCoy” surrounded by a rectangular box and simply the word “USA” beneath it; also known as the “script” mark. However, earlier pieces dating from 1910-1925 may bear the company’s name within a simple circle.

Some of the earliest marks include “The Nelson McCoy Sanitary Stoneware Co.” and “McCoy Pottery”. It’s important to note that variations in spelling, font, and placement of the mark can indicate different periods and authenticity.

2. Study the Glaze:

Mccoy Pottery is known for its distinctive glazes, and this is a key factor to look out for when identifying their pieces. From smooth matte finishes to glossy drip patterns, each glaze has its unique characteristics. Familiarize yourself with the different types of glazes used by Mccoy Pottery throughout its history – such as aqua green or turquoise “Blossomtime” glaze from the 1940s and the popular speckled “Cookie Jar” glaze from the 1950s.

3. Examine the Shape and Design:

The shape and design of a piece can also indicate its authenticity. Mccoy Pottery has a signature style known for its simplistic, yet elegant designs often featuring floral or geometric patterns. For instance, the popular “Jardinier” planters have a round shape with a flared rim and embossed patterns on the sides. Additionally, looking out for unique features like handles or spouts can also help in identifying Mccoy Pottery.

4. Check for Imperfections:

As with any handmade item, Mccoy Pottery may have slight imperfections. These can include variations in glaze application, small marks or bumps on the surface, or unevenness in the shape or thickness of a piece. These minor flaws are characteristic of Mccoy Pottery and add to its charm and authenticity.

5. Research Production Dates:

Mccoy Pottery was produced for over a century, so understanding the production dates can aid in identifying a piece’s authenticity. The company created many different lines and designs over the years, each with its specific production period. A quick online search or reference book on Mccoy Pottery can help you determine when a particular piece was made.

6. Look for Known Patterns:

Over the years, Mccoy Pottery introduced various patterns that became popular and sought after by collectors. These patterns often have unique names that can help in identifying pieces, such as “Mammy” or “Old Mill”. Researching these well-known patterns can assist in determining an item’s authenticity. This information can also be found in reference books or online resources.

7. Examine the Weight:

Mccoy Pottery is known for its sturdy, durable pieces that are often heavy due to their quality and thickness. If a piece feels too lightweight or flimsy, it may not be genuine Mccoy Pottery. However, this should be used as a secondary factor as some pieces, like smaller decorative items, can be lighter in weight.

8. Seek Expert Opinions:

If you are unsure about the authenticity of a piece, don’t hesitate to seek help from experts or experienced collectors. They may have valuable knowledge and insights that can assist in identifying Mccoy Pottery accurately. Online forums or antique shops specializing in pottery are also great resources to consult.

9. Familiarize Yourself with Fake Pieces:

Unfortunately, with the growing popularity and value of Mccoy Pottery, there has been an increase in fake or counterfeit items on the market. Keep yourself informed by researching common signs of fake pieces, such as non-authentic marks or glazes and modern materials used. Remember, if something seems too good to be true, it probably is.

Following these tips and tricks, you can confidently identify Mccoy Pottery pieces and add them to your collection with pride. Keep in mind that practice makes perfect, so don’t be discouraged if you make a mistake or two along the way. With time, you will become an expert at spotting genuine Mccoy Pottery items and appreciate the beauty and history behind each piece. Happy collecting!

Additional Tips and Tricks to Identify Mccoy Pottery

1. If you are looking to identify a specific piece of McCoy pottery, it is important to research and familiarize yourself with the different markings, stamps, and patterns used by the company. This will help you accurately determine the age and value of your piece.

2. McCoy pottery has been known for its distinct colors and glazes, such as matte or glossy finishes in earthy tones like green, brown, and yellow. Knowing the common colors used by McCoy can also help identify their pieces.

3. One way to identify authentic McCoy pottery is to look for imperfections or flaws in the piece, as mass-produced items tend to have a smoother and more uniform finish. This could include slight variations in glaze color, visible seams from the mold, or minor chips or cracks.

4. Another key factor in identifying McCoy pottery is to pay attention to the shape and style of the piece. McCoy was known for producing a variety of items, from vases and planters to cookie jars and dinnerware sets. Familiarizing yourself with the different styles can help you determine if your piece is truly authentic.

5. The bottoms of McCoy pottery pieces often contain important information, such as the company’s logo, date of production, and sometimes even the name of the specific design or pattern. This can be a helpful clue in identifying your piece.

6. If you are unsure about the authenticity of your McCoy pottery piece, it is always best to consult with an expert or collector who has more knowledge and experience in this area. They may be able to provide additional tips and tricks for identifying McCoy pottery, as well as assess the value of your piece.

7. Finally, it is important to keep in mind that there are many reproductions and knock-offs of McCoy pottery out there, especially with its rise in popularity among collectors. Be cautious when purchasing pieces from online marketplaces or antique stores, and always do your research before making a purchase.

Following these additional tips and tricks can help you become more knowledgeable in identifying McCoy pottery and avoid any potential scams or misidentified pieces. With some research, practice, and a discerning eye, you will be able to confidently identify and appreciate the beauty of authentic McCoy pottery. Happy hunting!

Frequently Asked Questions

How Can I Tell if My Mccoy Pottery Piece is Valuable or Rare?

The value and rarity of McCoy pottery pieces can vary greatly depending on factors such as their age, condition, and design. It is best to consult with an expert or do further research to determine the value of your specific piece.

Can I Find Mccoy Pottery at Garage Sales or Flea Markets?

Yes, it is possible to find McCoy pottery at garage sales or flea markets. However, always be cautious when purchasing from these places as there may be reproductions or knock-offs being sold. It is best to do your research and inspect the piece carefully before making a purchase.

Are There Any Other Companies That Produced Similar Pottery to Mccoy?

Yes, several companies produced similar pottery to McCoy, such as Hull, Shawnee, and Roseville. However, each company had its distinct characteristics and markings that can help differentiate its pieces from McCoy’s pottery. It is important to research and familiarize yourself with these companies as well if you are interested in collecting pottery.

Can I Use Dishwashers or Microwaves on My Mccoy Pottery?

McCoy pottery was not designed to withstand the high heat and harsh chemicals of dishwashers and microwaves. It is best to hand wash your McCoy pieces with mild soap and warm water and avoid using them for cooking or reheating food. This will help preserve the integrity and value of your pottery.

Is There a Difference Between Collectible and Decorative Mccoy Pottery?

While all McCoy pottery pieces are collectible, some may hold more value and significance to collectors due to their rarity, design, or historical importance. Some pieces may also be considered decorative rather than collectible, as they were meant to be used for practical purposes such as holding plants or serving food. Ultimately, the value and collectibility of McCoy pottery are subjective and can vary from person to person. 

Conclusion

All in all, knowing how to identify mccoy pottery can be a fun and rewarding experience for collectors and enthusiasts alike. It is important to familiarize yourself with the company’s history, markings, colors, and styles to accurately identify and appreciate these beautiful pieces of American art pottery. By following these tips and tricks, you can become confident in your ability to recognize authentic McCoy pottery and avoid any potential scams or misidentified pieces. Happy hunting!